Federico Viticci said it best on the Connected podcast last week: The departure of Angela Ahrendts as Apple’s retail chief is a Rorschach test. One’s reaction to the news will reveal a lot about one’s feelings about the current state of Apple’s retail stores.

I’ve seen a lot of criticism of Ahrendts featuring aspects of the Apple Store experience that actually preceded her. No, she didn’t invent the where’s-the-line, where-do-I-stand set-up that completely breaks everything we ever learned about how to behave in a retail store. Under her tenure the approach was modified, not discarded, and in recent years I’ve noticed a more aggressive positioning of employees at the front of stores to intercept new shoppers and put them in the right place.

Perhaps the biggest source of Apple Store frustration in recent years wasn’t based on any Apple Retail initiative. It was the decision to address a public-relations nightmare involving failing batteries that impacted iPhone speeds by offering a yearlong, discounted battery-replacement program. That bit of damage control flooded Apple Stores with traffic and repair jobs it was not prepared to handle. Service suffered as a result.

A stable force for Apple retail

My gut feeling is that overall, Ahrendts did just what she was hired to do. In the wake of one of the worst executive hires Apple has ever made, she provided stability and a deep knowledge of the retail world. Apple has opened a new set of showcase stores in major cities with an entirely new store design. The new Today at Apple curriculum, featuring more than four dozen new courses designed to help people use their Apple devices for practical and creative pursuits, just launched and by most accounts is quite good.
ap keynote 2017 wrap up angela today at apple Apple
Angela Ahrendts was hired in 2013 to oversee Apple’s retail efforts.

Then there’s the Apple Watch, a product unlike anything Apple has ever made before. The arrival of the Watch forced some creative thinking in terms of letting people try on different watch models and a plethora of watch bands. If you’ve never tried on an Apple Watch at an Apple store, you’re missing out—it’s a really well-thought-out experience right down to all the hidden drawers and cleaning cloths.

Still, perhaps what Ahrendts was hired to do five years ago isn’t what Tim Cook and the rest of Apple’s leadership want out of retail today. Ahrendts’ fashion-industry resume may have seemed more relevant when Apple was planning on launching that gold Apple Watch Edition, but that strategy has been folded. The beautiful new stores and detailed course curriculum suggest a company that viewed massive retail sales as a given—when current sales suggest that the iPhone is no longer selling itself and that Apple Store staff needs to spend time actively convincing customers to buy.

The future of the Apple Store

My hope for the future of the Apple Store is that it goes back to basics, focusing not just on product sales but on service. Back in the day, the Genius Bar made Apple’s retail efforts stand out—but today I hear far more complaints than compliments about post-sale support in Apple Stores. Some of that is understandably due to Apple’s enormous growth, of course, but Apple Retail has to figure out a way to cope with that growth.

I’m an Apple customer whose closest Apple Store is not one of the big flagship entries but a small one in a nearby outdoor shopping mall. As spacious and impressive as Apple’s glass boxes in San Francisco, Chicago, and elsewhere are, my local store is small and crowded, sometimes unpleasantly so. The employees there smile and work hard and my experiences there have generally been positive, but between the tables of products and the benches and giant screens and the rest, it’s 50 pounds of Apple stuffed into a 25-pound bag.